Short pay: how to catch it and dispute it
Why a broker pays less than the invoice, how to check every payment against the rate con, and how to dispute a short pay with paperwork instead of phone calls.
A short pay is a payment that comes in under what you invoiced. Sometimes it's a mistake. Sometimes it's a deduction you agreed to and forgot about. Sometimes it's a deduction you never agreed to. The only way to tell which is to check every payment against the invoice, line by line, the day it arrives.
Why short pays happen
The rate doesn't match
The rate con was revised, for an added stop or a better rate, and accounts payable paid the original. Or the invoice didn't match the rate con to begin with, and the broker paid the lower number. Always invoice from the final signed rate con, and attach that version.
An accessorial went missing
The broker approved detention or a lumper by email, but the approval never made it into the broker's billing system. Accounts payable pays what the rate con says and nothing more. This is why the approval belongs in the invoice packet, not just in your inbox.
A deduction came out
Some deductions are legitimate. Some aren't. The common ones:
- Advances. A lumper or fuel advance sent as a Comchek or EFS code gets taken back out of your pay. That's fine, as long as the matching reimbursement was added too. See lumper fees: getting your money back.
- Quick pay fees. If you chose quick pay, the fee comes off the top. If you didn't choose it, it shouldn't be there.
- Fees in the carrier agreement. Some broker-carrier agreements list charges for late paperwork, late delivery or missed tracking updates. If you signed it, it may apply. Ask for the clause.
- Claim offsets. The broker holds back money against a cargo damage or shortage claim.
The payment went to the wrong invoice
Two loads with the same broker in the same week, one payment, and the money gets split wrong. The total looks close, but one invoice is overpaid and one is short.
Catch it the day the money lands
- Get the remittance advice. That's the broker's breakdown of which invoices a payment covers and what came out. If a deposit shows up as one lump sum with no breakdown, ask for it.
- Match it to the invoice. Linehaul, each accessorial, each deduction. Not just the total.
- Flag every gap, even a small one. A $25 difference might be a fee you agreed to or a mistake. You won't know until you ask.
- Keep a record per broker. How many days they took to pay and whether they paid short. Over a few months that tells you which brokers to book with and which to price higher.
At year end, the 1099-NEC a broker sends you should match what you were actually paid. A short pay you never chased will show up there too. 1099-NEC from brokers: reconcile it covers that check.
Worked example
The original rate con paid $2,000. The broker revised it to $2,250 after adding a stop. The broker approved 1h 35m of detention by email at $60 an hour, which is 1.5833 × $60 = $95.00. The broker sent a $200 Comchek for the lumper as an advance, and the rate con says lumpers are reimbursed with a receipt.
You invoiced $2,345.00. The deposit was $1,800.00.
| Line | Invoiced | Paid | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Linehaul (revised rate con) | $2,250.00 | $2,000.00 | −$250.00 |
| Detention (approved by email) | $95.00 | $0.00 | −$95.00 |
| Lumper reimbursement (receipt) | $200.00 | $0.00 | −$200.00 |
| Lumper advance (Comchek) | −$200.00 | −$200.00 | $0.00 |
| Total | $2,345.00 | $1,800.00 | −$545.00 |
Three separate problems, each one ordinary: the original rate paid instead of the revised one, an approval that didn't reach billing, and an advance taken back with no reimbursement added. Checked only against the total, it looks like "about $500 short." Checked line by line, it's three specific amounts, each with a document that proves it.
Dispute it with paperwork
Send one email, not a string of phone calls. If you do call first, follow up in writing. Put in:
- your invoice number, the broker's load number, the payment date and the amount paid
- the line-by-line table: what you invoiced, what they paid, the difference
- the documents: the final rate con, the approval email, the lumper receipt, the signed POD and your original invoice
- a clear request and a date
Something like:
Short pay on invoice [number], load [reference number]. Invoiced $2,345.00; paid $1,800.00 on [date]. Balance: $545.00. (1) Linehaul paid at $2,000; revised rate confirmation dated [date] shows $2,250, a difference of $250.00. (2) Detention of $95.00 approved by [name] on [date], not paid. (3) Lumper advance of $200.00 deducted; the $200.00 reimbursement per the rate confirmation was not added. Documents attached. Please pay the $545.00 balance, or tell me which line you dispute, by [date].
Send it to the broker's accounts payable address and copy the person who booked the load. If a deduction turns out to be a real fee from a carrier agreement you signed, accept it, but ask for the clause in writing so you know what to avoid next time.
If it doesn't move
- Follow up once on the date you gave, with the same email and attachments.
- If you factor, tell your factoring company. Then read your factoring agreement, because it decides who absorbs a short pay. Some let the factor charge the difference back to you.
- If the broker doesn't pay at all, every licensed property broker has to carry a $75,000 surety bond or trust fund (49 CFR 387.307). You can look up a broker's bond on FMCSA's Licensing and Insurance site. The bond is meant for nonpayment, not for a missing $25.
- Watch the clock. Federal law sets an 18-month limit, from when the claim accrues, for a carrier to sue for unpaid charges (49 U.S.C. 14705). Your broker-carrier agreement may set a much shorter window for disputing an invoice, and that's the one to watch. Don't sit on it.
The best defense is upstream: a rate con that spells out every charge, approvals in writing, and an invoice packet that includes them. Accessorial charges: the full list you can bill and the invoice packet that gets paid fastest cover both. And a broker who short-pays more than once is telling you something. How to check a broker before you book helps you hear it sooner.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Fifth Wheel tracks who owes you, how many days past terms each invoice is, and each broker's real pay history, including average days to pay and short pays. When a payment comes in short, it writes the rate discrepancy letter, and when one is late, a polite past-due reminder in three stages. You send them from your own mail app.
Try it
Before you dispute a detention or fuel surcharge line, check your own number first. The calculators price detention to the minute and rerun the fuel surcharge at the week's DOE price, so the figure in your letter is right.
Keep reading
- Accessorial charges: the full list you can billDetention, layover, TONU, lumper, extra stops, driver assist, reconsignment, tarping and more. What each accessorial pays for and the proof that gets it paid.
- BOL and POD: what to check before you signWhat the bill of lading and proof of delivery each prove, what to check before you sign either one, and how one wrong count becomes a short pay.
- How to check a broker before you book the loadLook up a broker's authority and bond on FMCSA, read its days-to-pay and credit signals, spot double brokering, and check your own pay history first.
Fifth Wheel does this from your paperwork
Scan the rate con, the BOL and the fuel receipts into the load. The app reads the numbers and tells you the one thing each load still needs. 5 loads free.