The cheapest diesel isn't the one on the sign
IFTA credits back the fuel tax in the pump price, so pump price minus that state's tax is the real comparison. Worked out with fourth-quarter 2026 rates.
Two truck stops on either side of a state line, 40 cents apart on the sign. The cheap one looks like the easy call. Under IFTA, it often isn't, because part of what you pay at the pump comes back to you, and that part is different in every state.
Where the fuel tax really goes
The price on the sign includes that state's fuel tax. But under IFTA, you don't owe fuel tax where you buy the fuel. You owe it where you burn it: each state gets tax on the gallons your miles there used, which is miles in that state ÷ your MPG. The tax you already paid at the pump is credited back on your quarterly return. The IFTA return post walks through that math.
The rule is in the IFTA Articles of Agreement: you "may claim a tax-paid credit on the IFTA tax return for fuel purchased at retail only when the fuel is placed into the fuel storage unit of a qualified motor vehicle and the purchase price includes fuel tax paid to a member jurisdiction" (R1010).
So the tax on your miles is the same no matter where you fill up. What changes is how much of the pump price comes back as a credit.
The real comparison
net price = pump price − that state's IFTA diesel rate
That's what a gallon costs you once the return is filed. Compare stops on that, not on the sign. The federal excise tax is the same in every state, so it drops out of the comparison.
Worked example: Illinois or Missouri
IFTA diesel rates for the fourth quarter of 2026 (October to December), from the IFTA tax rate matrix: Illinois $0.738 a gallon, Missouri $0.295. Both are unchanged from the third quarter. The matrix notes that fourth-quarter rates aren't final until December 4, 2026, so check it before you rely on them.
The pump prices here are examples, not real quotes. A 150-gallon fill:
| Illinois | Missouri | |
|---|---|---|
| Sign price | $6.49 | $6.09 |
| IFTA rate, credited back | $0.738 | $0.295 |
| Net price per gallon | $5.752 | $5.795 |
| 150 gallons at the sign | $973.50 | $913.50 |
| Credit on the IFTA return | −$110.70 | −$44.25 |
| Net cost of the fill | $862.80 | $869.25 |
The Missouri sign is 40 cents cheaper. Illinois is 4.3 cents a gallon cheaper once the credit comes back, $6.45 on the fill.
That's not a fortune on one stop. The point is the direction: the sign told you the wrong answer.
The break-even gap
The tax difference between the two states is $0.738 − $0.295 = $0.443 a gallon. That's the gap that matters:
- Missouri's sign more than 44.3 cents below Illinois: Missouri is cheaper.
- Less than 44.3 cents below: Illinois is cheaper, even with the higher sign.
- About 44.3 cents: a wash.
When the cheap sign really is cheaper
When the sign gap is bigger than the tax gap. Say Illinois is $6.79 and Missouri $6.09. That's 70 cents on the sign against a 44.3-cent tax gap. Illinois nets $6.052 and Missouri $5.795, so Missouri wins by 25.7 cents a gallon, $38.55 on 150 gallons.
When the two states tax diesel about the same. Texas is $0.200 and Oklahoma $0.190 in the same matrix. With a one-cent tax gap, the sign tells you nearly everything.
During a tax holiday, with a catch. Ohio cut its diesel tax from 47 cents to effectively zero from October 4, 2026 through January 2, 2027 (Ohio Department of Taxation), and the IFTA matrix shows Ohio at $0.0001 for that stretch. An Ohio sign during the holiday has almost no state tax in it, and there's almost nothing to credit back, so the Ohio sign is close to the net price.
Compare it with the other state's net price, not its sign. Against Pennsylvania at $0.741, an Ohio stop has to be more than 74 cents below the Pennsylvania sign to come out ahead. When the holiday ends, check the first-quarter 2027 matrix for Ohio's rate.
When the cheap stop is off your route. Ten miles out and ten back is 20 miles. At 6.5 MPG and $6.38 diesel that's about 98 cents a mile in fuel, plus around 20 cents in other running costs. Twenty miles at about $1.18 is roughly $24, far more than the $6.45 the Illinois stop saved above.
When your discount is bigger on one side. If your fuel program takes money off at one chain and not the other, use what you actually pay:
net price = pump price − your discount − that state's IFTA rate
The credit only works if the receipt does
You only get the credit if the purchase goes on your return and the receipt holds up. The IFTA Procedures Manual (P550) asks for the date, the seller's name and address, the gallons, the fuel type, the price, the truck's unit number and the purchaser's name. An electronic or digital record of the original receipt counts. A receipt you can't read, or one that doesn't tie to your truck, is a credit you can lose in an audit.
One more thing: fueling heavy in a high-tax state you don't run much means more cash out at the pump now and a bigger credit later. The credit shows up when you file, up to a month after the quarter ends. If cash is tight that week, that matters too.
The sign is one input, not the answer
None of this changes what you owe each state for your miles. It only changes what you pay for the fuel. Think in net prices and you'll stop paying extra for the cheap-looking sign.
If diesel is eating your margin no matter where you buy it, that's a rate problem. Diesel over $6 works out what your break-even needs at today's price.
This is general information, not tax advice. Your base state's IFTA office and your preparer have the final word.
Fifth Wheel's Fuel screen ranks the states you've bought diesel in by price after their IFTA tax, cheapest first, from the fuel receipts you scan. The same app keeps the IFTA worksheet for your quarterly return.
Try it
Put two or more pump prices into the diesel net price calculator. It takes each state's IFTA diesel rate off and shows which stop is really cheaper.
Keep reading
- A maintenance reserve: how many cents a mile to set asideWhat a maintenance reserve has to cover, how to pick your cents per mile from your own truck's repair history, and why 12 cents is only a place to start.
- Deadhead miles: how to price them into every loadWhy empty miles belong in your per-mile math, how to price deadhead in and out of a load, and when running empty to a better market pays for itself.
- How to counter a lowball rate with your own numbersKnow your floor, price the deadhead and the time, give one number on the phone and stop talking. A worked counter-offer, and when to walk away instead.
Fifth Wheel does this from your paperwork
Scan the rate con, the BOL and the fuel receipts into the load. The app reads the numbers and tells you the one thing each load still needs. 5 loads free.