Fifth Wheel Download the app

How to counter a lowball rate with your own numbers

Know your floor, price the deadhead and the time, give one number on the phone and stop talking. A worked counter-offer, and when to walk away instead.

A lowball offer isn't personal. It's an opening number from a broker trying to cover a load at the lowest rate someone will take. Your job is to know the lowest rate you should take before the phone rings, and to say a number above it.

Three numbers before you call

  1. Your floor. Break-even cost per mile times every mile the load takes. Below this, the load costs you money. If you don't know your break-even, start with cost per mile: the only number that matters.
  2. Your walk-away. Your floor plus the least you're willing to work for. You pick the margin. Say 20 cents a mile.
  3. Your ask. What you'd like to get, set a bit above where you expect to land, so there's room to meet in the middle without dropping under your walk-away.

Work them out on paper or in a calculator, not in your head while the broker waits.

Price every mile and the time

Miles. Deadhead to the pickup, the loaded miles, and the empty miles you expect to run after delivery. Deadhead miles: how to price them covers estimating that last part.

Time. Some loads tie up the truck longer than their miles do: a delivery appointment a day later than you could make it, a long wait to load, several stops. Your fixed cost per mile assumes the truck keeps moving. A day it sits is a day of fixed bills with no miles to spread them over.

With $6,500 a month in fixed costs, that's $6,500 ÷ 30 = about $217 a day. When a load costs you a day, add it.

Extras. Detention, layover, lumper and TONU terms belong on the rate con, agreed before you go. See accessorial charges you can bill for what to ask about.

Worked example

The offer: $1,600. You're 80 miles from the pickup. The load is 700 loaded miles into a slow market, where you expect to run 40 miles empty to reload. The receiver's appointment is a day later than you could get there, so the truck sits a day. Break-even is $1.90 a mile.

Step Amount
Total miles (80 + 700 + 40) 820
Floor (820 × $1.90) $1,558
Day sitting $217
Floor with the day $1,775
Walk-away (+ 20¢ × 820 = $164) $1,939
Ask (+ 40¢ × 820 = $328) $2,103
The offer $1,600

On miles alone, $1,600 ÷ 820 = $1.95 a mile, which looks like it clears a $1.90 break-even by a nickel. Count the day and it's $175 under your floor ($1,775 − $1,600). That's the load that looks fine on the board and loses money in real life.

Round the ask to $2,100 and the walk-away to $1,950.

What to say on the phone

Ask before you price. Weight, pickup and delivery times, how many stops, who unloads, the detention terms. Every answer can change your numbers, and asking shows you're running a business.

Give one number with one reason. Something like:

I can do it for $2,100. I'm 80 miles out, the receiver can't take it until Thursday, and I'll be running empty out of there.

Give a dollar amount, not a range. A range tells the broker your low end, and that's the number you'll get.

Then stop talking. Don't fill the silence with a lower number. Let the broker answer.

If they come back, meet them above your walk-away. If they offer $2,000, that's above $1,950. Take it. If they offer $1,850, it isn't.

If it's still under, say so politely and leave the door open:

I can't do it under $1,950. If it's still open this afternoon, give me a call.

A load nobody takes at the low number gets re-posted, and a load still on the board that afternoon can pay more than it did that morning.

Get the agreed number on the rate con before you roll. A rate said on the phone isn't a rate until it's in writing, along with the extras. What a rate confirmation hides covers what else to check on that page.

When to walk

  • The best offer is under your walk-away. You decided that number with a clear head. Don't renegotiate it with yourself on the phone.
  • The broker won't put detention, layover or TONU terms in writing. That load is likely to cost you more than it shows.
  • The broker pays slowly or short. A higher rate from a slow payer can be worth the same as a lower one from a good one; see how to check a broker before you book.

Write down every counter: the offer, your number, and where it landed. After a month you'll know which lanes and which brokers move, and which never do.

The one exception

Sometimes a load under your floor still beats sitting. Your running cost is fuel plus other variable costs: 98¢ + 20¢ = $1.18 a mile on the example truck. The fixed bills arrive whether you drive or not.

If the truck would otherwise sit, the $1,600 load covers the 820 miles of running cost ($967.60) and puts $632.40 toward bills you owe anyway. That can be the right call, especially if it moves you to a better market. Make it on purpose, with the number in front of you, and not more than once in a while.

The cost-per-mile calculator builds your floor from your own costs and checks a load's pay against loaded and empty miles, so your three numbers are ready before you call.

This is general information, not legal advice.

Fifth Wheel's Diesel Check takes the rate, the loaded miles and the deadhead, and shows whether a load covers today's diesel at your MPG and clears your break-even floor. It suggests a counter-offer that does, at your floor plus a quarter a mile. When you type the broker's name on a new load, it shows that broker's real pay history from your own loads.

Try it

Before the next call, put the offer's pay, loaded miles and empty miles into the cost-per-mile calculator and write down your floor, your walk-away and your ask.