How fuel surcharges are calculated, and why yours is short
The DOE-indexed fuel surcharge formula, worked at today's diesel, and the five ways a surcharge ends up covering less of your fuel than it looks like it should.
A fuel surcharge line on a rate con looks like it should cover your diesel. Often it covers less than you expect. To see why, start with how the number is built.
The common formula
Most indexed surcharges follow the same shape:
surcharge per mile = (weekly national diesel average − base price) ÷ MPG figure
The weekly average is the DOE/EIA national on-highway diesel price, which EIA publishes every week. A typical base is $1.20 a gallon, though some contracts use $1.25 or another number. A typical MPG basis is 6, though some use 5 or 6.5.
Those three inputs, the base, the MPG and which week's price, are all in the contract. Check your own contract or rate con for the base, the MPG and which week's price it uses. Do not assume.
Worked at today's diesel
The EIA national average for the week of Sep 28, 2026 was $6.382. With a $1.20 base and 6 MPG:
($6.382 − $1.20) ÷ 6 = $5.182 ÷ 6 = $0.864
That is 86 cents a mile. Most surcharges are paid on loaded miles, so on a load of 612 loaded miles (and 40 empty to reach it) that is about $526.
What the surcharge is meant to cover
The surcharge covers only the part of the fuel price above the base. The first $1.20 a gallon, which is $1.20 ÷ 6 = 20 cents a mile, is supposed to be inside the linehaul rate.
So if you compare the surcharge to your total fuel bill, you will always see a gap. That gap is not the problem. The honest comparison is the surcharge against the formula at this week's DOE price.
For reference, your actual fuel on that load, all 652 miles at 6.5 MPG, is about 100 gallons, and at $6.38 that is about $640. The formula pays about $526 of it. The rest, the base part of every gallon and the diesel for the empty miles, is meant to come out of the linehaul.
Five ways it comes up short
1. A stale index
The surcharge may have been set from an older week's DOE price: a monthly update, or a table nobody refreshed. Diesel moved from $6.285 the week of Sep 14 to $6.529 the week of Sep 21. That is 24 cents a gallon in a week, or about 4 cents a mile at 6 MPG. When diesel is rising, every week of lag costs you.
2. All-in rates
With no separate fuel surcharge line, you cannot tell whether fuel was priced in at all. Divide the all-in rate by all the miles, empty ones included, and compare the result to your break-even at today's diesel. If your break-even was built on last year's fuel price, it is out of date. The cost-per-mile post shows how to build it, and diesel over $6 works it at today's price.
3. An MPG basis higher than your truck gets
A table built on 6.5 MPG pays less per mile than one built on 6. At today's price, with a $1.20 base:
- 6 MPG basis: $5.182 ÷ 6 = $0.864 a mile
- 6.5 MPG basis: $5.182 ÷ 6.5 = $0.797 a mile
That is about 7 cents a mile, roughly $41 on 612 loaded miles. If your truck gets 6 MPG, the difference is yours to absorb.
4. Loaded miles only
The surcharge is usually paid on loaded miles. Your deadhead burns diesel too. Forty empty miles at 6.5 MPG is about 6 gallons, close to $39 at $6.38, and no surcharge line pays for it. Those miles have to be covered by the rate.
5. Your region costs more than the national average
The surcharge follows the national number. Your pump may not. For the week of Sep 28, California averaged $8.181 and the Midwest $6.526, against a national $6.382. That is $1.80 a gallon above the national price in California and about 14 cents a gallon above it in the Midwest. If you fuel where diesel runs higher than the national average, the surcharge is short by that difference.
What to do about it
Ask three questions before you accept:
- Which week's DOE price does the surcharge use?
- What base does it use?
- What MPG does it use?
Then check the answer in the fuel surcharge calculator. Enter the DOE price, the base and the MPG, and see what the formula says it should be. If the line on the rate con is lower, you know the gap and can ask about it.
When the rate is all-in, judge it against your break-even at today's diesel. If it falls short, counter with a number: the per-mile rate you need, times all the miles.
You do not need to argue about the formula. You need to know what it should say, so you can see where your load sits against it.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Fifth Wheel's Diesel Check helps here. When a rate con lists the fuel surcharge on its own line, Diesel Check shows how much of the load's diesel it covers, alongside what the load leaves you at today's diesel. Checking a load does not save anything or use one of your 5 free loads.
Try it
Enter this week's DOE price, your contract's base and its MPG basis in the fuel surcharge calculator, and compare the result to the surcharge on your next rate con.
Keep reading
- A maintenance reserve: how many cents a mile to set asideWhat a maintenance reserve has to cover, how to pick your cents per mile from your own truck's repair history, and why 12 cents is only a place to start.
- Deadhead miles: how to price them into every loadWhy empty miles belong in your per-mile math, how to price deadhead in and out of a load, and when running empty to a better market pays for itself.
- How to counter a lowball rate with your own numbersKnow your floor, price the deadhead and the time, give one number on the phone and stop talking. A worked counter-offer, and when to walk away instead.
Fifth Wheel does this from your paperwork
Scan the rate con, the BOL and the fuel receipts into the load. The app reads the numbers and tells you the one thing each load still needs. 5 loads free.